Cooking With Extra Virgin Olive Oil: Good or Bad?

9
15830
Last Updated on

Over the past several decades, dietary fat has often had an undeserved “unhealthy” reputation.

While this mindset is changing in recent times, one particular fat—extra virgin olive oil—has long held a “heart-healthy” reputation.

Furthermore, scientific research widely supports the idea that olive oil is generally beneficial.

However, it is common to hear claims that we shouldn’t use extra virgin olive oil for cooking.

Is there any truth to this?

In this article, we examine this claim in more detail, followed by a look at what the research says about cooking with extra virgin olive oil.

Extra Virgin Olive Oil Being Poured On Green Olives.

Why do people claim we shouldn’t cook with extra virgin olive oil?

First of all, fatty acids are prone to oxidation from heat, light, and oxygen. For this reason, the process of frying with oil can cause some of the fat to oxidize.

Furthermore, this oxidation process can lead to the production of secondary oxidation products such as aldehydes and other polar compounds. Research shows that these compounds can have adverse effects, and chronic exposure may be detrimental to human health (1, 2).

However, oils which are repeatedly heated are the biggest source of oxidation products (3).

Saturation

Furthermore, the specific fatty acids within a cooking oil play a role in how prone to oxidation it is.

Saturated fats are the most stable fatty acids, hence they are most resistant to oxidation (4).

Since olive oil is predominantly an unsaturated fat, some people claim it is not suitable for cooking.

Smoke point

The smoke point of oil—the temperature at which the oil starts to burn—is another metric that people use to judge the merits of a particular cooking fat.

In this regard, various sources suggest that extra virgin olive oil has a smoke point somewhere between 191°C (376°F) and 215°C (419°F) (5, 6).

This smoke point is much lower than cooking fats such as ghee (250°C/482°F) and refined avocado oil (271°C/520°F) (7, 8).

Key Point: Some people believe that extra virgin olive oil is unsuitable to use as a cooking oil. People generally believe this due to olive oil’s level of saturation and low-ish smoke point.

However, the fatty acids in olive oil are reasonably heat-stable

Is there really good reason to fear cooking with extra virgin olive oil?

Let’s first look at the oil’s fatty acid breakdown.

According to the USDA Food Composition Database, extra virgin olive oil contains the following amounts of fatty acids per 100 grams (9);

  • Saturated Fat: 13.8 g
  • Monounsaturated Fat: 73.0 g
  • Polyunsaturated Fat: 10.5 g

The Different Saturation Levels of Fat

Firstly, there are three primary groups of fatty acids, and these are as follows;

  • Saturated fat
  • Monounsaturated fat
  • Polyunsaturated fat

All three of these fats contain the elements carbon and hydrogen.

In saturated fat, the carbon atoms are entirely “saturated” (surrounded) by hydrogen atoms, and the fat molecule contains no double bonds.

For this reason, they are very resistant to oxidation (10).

The following diagram shows the molecular structure of saturated fat;

Chemical Structure of a Saturated Fatty Acid.

In contrast, monounsaturated fatty acids contain one (mono) carbon-carbon double bond and they are not fully saturated with hydrogen. This double bond can be broken, which makes monounsaturated fat slightly more prone to oxidation than saturated fat (11).

Here is the structure of a monounsaturated fatty acid;

Chemical Structure of Monounsaturated Fatty Acid.

Lastly, polyunsaturated fats contain multiple (poly) double bonds, and they are more prone to oxidation than other fatty acids (12).

The diagram below shows one example of a polyunsaturated fatty acid which, in this case, has two double bonds;

Chemical Structure of a Polyunsaturated Fatty Acid.

Since olive oil is around 90% saturated and monounsaturated fat, it is fairly resistant to oxidation.

Regarding these fatty acid ratios, it is easy to hear claims that animal fats are heat stable but that olive oil isn’t.

Interestingly though, extra virgin olive oil has a similar fatty acid ratio to lard, and both contain the same amount of polyunsaturated fat – around 10/11 ml per 100 ml (13, 14).

Key Point: Olive oil isn’t as saturated as some cooking fats, but structurally, it is still fairly resistant to oxidation.

The smoke point of an oil doesn’t represent the oil’s oxidative stability

Many of us judge the relative benefits of cooking oil with a sole focus on the smoke point.

However, research demonstrates that the fatty acids in cooking oil can breakdown before an oil even hits that smoke point.

For example, a recent study compared the chemical and physical changes in ten commercial oils while heating them at a temperature of 180°C (356°F), among various other heat/time tests (15).

These oils were as follows;

  • Avocado oil (non-refined)
  • Canola oil
  • Coconut oil
  • Extra virgin olive oil
  • Grapeseed oil
  • Olive oil
  • Peanut oil
  • Rice bran oil
  • Sunflower oil
  • Virgin olive oil

What Did the Study Show?

To directly quote the researchers;

From this study, it can be concluded that, under different heating conditions, the generation of polar compounds with temperature and time was more pronounced for refined seed oils with higher initial values of smoke point” (16).

For those unaware, the term “seed oil” is another name for common vegetable oils (which are actually from seeds rather than vegetables) such as canola and grapeseed oil.

The table below shows the final amount of polar compounds each oil generated, as well as the oil’s smoke point in the test;

Final Polar Compound Values and Smoke Point For Various Cooking Oils
Type of Cooking Oil% Final Polar CompoundsSmoke Point (°C)
Avocado oil (non-refined)11.60197°C (387°F)
Canola oil22.43256°C (493°F)
Coconut oil9.30191°C (376°F)
Extra virgin olive oil8.47207°C (405°F)
Grapeseed oil19.79268°C (514°F)
Olive oil11.65208°C (406°F)
Peanut oil10.71226°C (439°F)
Rice bran oil14.35237°C (459°F)
Sunflower oil15.57255°C (491°F)
Virgin olive oil10.71175°C (347°F)

As shown in the table, the smoke point of each oil had little relevance to the number of oxidation products the oil generated.

In this study, extra virgin olive oil generated a lower amount of polar compounds than any other cooking fat.

Key Point: Extra virgin olive oil does not have a high smoke point, but a recent study suggests it generates fewer oxidation products than oils with much higher smoke points.

Extra virgin olive oil is rich in antioxidants and polyphenols

Another point worthy of consideration is that extra virgin olive oil is a rich source of polyphenols as well as the antioxidant vitamin E.

For example, olive oil contains approximately 2 mg of vitamin E per tablespoon, which is equivalent to around 10% of the recommended daily intake (17).

Vitamin E has antioxidant properties, and research demonstrates that it can increase the resistance of fatty acids to oxidation (18).

Additionally, extra virgin olive oil is one of the richest dietary sources of polyphenols. These specific polyphenols include hydroxytyrosol, tyrosol, oleuropein, and oleocanthal (19).

Initial research suggests that these compounds can also help protect fatty acids from oxidizing (20, 21).

Key Point: Extra virgin olive oil contains numerous compounds that help to prevent oxidative damage during the cooking process.

What Does Research Show About Cooking With Olive Oil?

Several studies have tested how olive oil performs when exposed to high-heat cooking temperatures.

Here is a brief summary of some relevant research;

  • In one study, researchers used several commercial oils for deep frying and took samples of each oil every three hours. Compared to commercial vegetable oil blends, extra virgin oil had lower levels of oxidation (22).
  • Much lower concentrations of aldehydes form when shallow frying fish in extra virgin olive oil compared to sunflower oil (23).
  • In one trial, potatoes were deep-fried in either extra virgin olive oil, peanut oil, or canola oil. During the frying process, extra virgin olive oil formed fewer aldehydes and polar compounds than the other two oils (24).
  • In a study featuring 20 participants, eating a breakfast fried with extra virgin olive oil led to lower levels of postprandial oxidative stress compared to either canola or sunflower oil (25).
Key Point: A variety of studies show that extra virgin olive oil is among the best cooking oils.

Final Thoughts

Extra virgin olive oil is primarily a source of monounsaturated fatty acids.

While not quite as stable as saturated fat, these fatty acids are reasonably resistant to oxidation, and olive oil contains a range of protective antioxidant compounds too.

For these reasons, cooking with olive oil appears to be a reasonably good choice.

However, while olive oil might be a good choice for the kitchen, it is important to buy a good quality oil.

Unfortunately, there have been several scandals with olive oil in recent years. Sadly, there have been cases of adulterated oil falsely being passed off as extra virgin olive oil.

For more information on trustworthy brands, see this list of olive oils. Each of these products are part of certificate schemes which submit to random and independent testing.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
9 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Shameer Mulji
Shameer Mulji
11 months ago

How does it compare with butter / ghee?

Shameer Mulji
Shameer Mulji
11 months ago
Reply to  Michael Joseph

Thanks!

Cill
Cill
11 months ago

For years now I’ve been using virgin olive oil to cook with and much prefer it to other vegetable oils on sale. I’ve never had any issues when using it as a base to fry foods in, ie onions, garlic etc, and roast potatoes basted in virgin olive oil always turn out perfectly.

George
George
1 year ago

Coconut oil was not mentioned. I understand that coconut oil is much healthier than olive oil. Is this correct?

Pacho
Pacho
6 months ago
Reply to  Michael Joseph

I’ve read coconut oil has one of the highest smoke points but in the table it ranks lower than Olive oil. Are there different types of coconut oil?