Soybean Oil: Healthy or Harmful?

34
110507
Last Updated on

Soybean oil is a commercial cooking oil used in a large number of fast food and ultra-processed food products.

However, this vegetable oil is controversial and splits opinion.

While some people think it is “heart healthy,” others worry about its relatively poor stability at high temperatures.

This article takes an in-depth look at soybean oil, backed by scientific research.

How Is Soybean Oil Made?

Before we look into the oil’s nutritional properties, let’s first examine how the oil is produced.

First of all, unlike oils such as extra virgin olive oil, soybean oil is not cold-pressed.

In short; it is tough to squeeze oil out of seeds, and so the soybean oil production process uses;

  • Heat
  • Chemical solvents
  • Bleaching
  • Deodorizers

These steps are a necessary part of the process to extract edible oil from the soybeans, and the finished product is known as a ‘refined, bleached, and deodorized’ oil.

The Process

Here is a flow chart which fully shows each stage of soybean oil’s refining process;

A flow chart showing the manufacturing process involved in producing soybean oil.
(Source)

As you can see, producing soybean oil is quite complicated and requires numerous different stages.

This process involves (1);

  • Mechanical pressing using heat and pressure to extract the oil.
  • The residual oil left in the soybean meal is then extracted using a solvent called hexane.
  • Since hexane is a toxin, this solvent then needs removing from the oil. This removal process uses steam and vacuums.
  • The oil also needs bleaching, which is a step used to remove impurities from the oil.
  • Finally, the oil undergoes a deodorization process to remove oxidation products in the oil. This deodorizing stage involves a high-temperature steam distillation process (180-220°C).

However, this process isn’t unique to only soybean oil. Other refined, bleached, and deodorized oils, such as Canola oil, also use it.

Key Point:The production of soybean oil requires a complex process and the oil is refined, bleached, and deodorized.

Soybean Oil Nutrition Facts

The following table shows the nutritional properties of soybean oil per tablespoon.

(Data source: NCCDB)

Soybean Oil Nutrition Facts
Calories/NutrientAmount% DV
Calories120 kcal
Carbohydrate0 g
Fat13.6 g
 – Saturated Fat2.1 g
 – Monounsaturated Fat3.1 g
 – Polyunsaturated Fat7.9 g
 – Omega-3 Fatty Acids0.9 g
 – Omega-6 Fatty Acids6.9 g
Protein0 g
Vitamin E1.11 mg5.5%
Vitamin K25.1 mcg31.3%
Selenium6.24 mcg8.9%

As shown in the nutrition values, soybean oil is primarily a source of omega-6 polyunsaturated fat.

Is Soybean Oil a Healthy Cooking Oil?

There have been many questions asked over soybean oil’s suitability as a healthy cooking oil.

Here are some important considerations.

Soybean Oil Is High In Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids, Which Are Prone To Oxidation

Firstly, out of the three main types of fatty acids, saturated fats are the most stable when exposed to high heat temperatures (2).

This is because they are “fully saturated.”

In other words; the carbon atoms in the fat are tightly surrounded by hydrogen atoms, which helps to prevent oxygen from ‘oxidizing’ the carbon atoms.

The Structure of Saturated Fat.
The molecular structure of saturated fat

On the other hand, polyunsaturated oils have numerous double bonds (gaps) exposing the carbon atoms to oxygen.Molecular Structure of Polyunsaturated Fat.

This means that instead of linking to a hydrogen atom, the carbon atom has two links with another carbon atom.

However, this ‘double bond’ makes polyunsaturated fatty acids more prone to oxidation.

As shown in the diagram above, this particular polyunsaturated fatty acid has two double bonds. Others may have more.

For this reason, soybean oil has poor oxidative stability compared to fats with a higher degree of saturation, such as butter, extra virgin olive oil, and avocado oil.

Key Point: Due to its large amount of omega-6 fatty acids, soybean oil is not heat-stable and is prone to oxidation.

Studies On Soybean Oil’s Oxidative Stability

One study investigated the rates of oxidative deterioration for soybean oil, corn oil, and olive oil. After using the oils for frying at 180°C, soybean oil oxidized more (and faster) than the other two oils (3).

Another study showed that heating soybean oil at 185°C (365°F) for two hours led to the formation of 4-hydroxy-2-trans-nonenal (HNE). HNE is an oxidation product that has mutagenic and cytotoxic properties (4).

Additionally, in a rat study, prolonged intake of re-heated soybean oil caused the rats to develop high blood pressure and vascular inflammation (5).

Of course, rats are not humans, and we should try not to re-heat any oil. That said, it is not unusual for fast food restaurants to use (or re-use) oil for extended periods.

Furthermore, a study examined the oxidative stability of soybean oil during storage. This study found that blending soybean oil with other oils, including sesame oil and peanut oil, made it more stable (6).

The researchers concluded that the greater oxidative stability of the blended oil was likely because polyunsaturated fatty acids decreased while monounsaturated fatty acids increased.

Key Point: Soybean oil is a rich source of polyunsaturated fatty acids, and is thereby not as heat-stable as some other cooking oils.

Excessive Soybean Oil Intake and Obesity

Look around, and it’s clear to see that Western society has an obesity problem.

For instance, 2 out of every 3 adults in the United States (68.8%) are either overweight or obese (7).

Some people lay the blame for this on red meat and animal fat, but the data does not support this.

Graph showing how red meat consumption and poultry has changed over the past several decades.
(Source)

As you can see, the consumption of red meat has fallen over the past several decades while leaner poultry increases in popularity.

Rates of sugar consumption, which is often a scapegoat for almost every health condition, have also been decreasing since the 1990s (8).

However, if we are looking for a possible dietary villain, then soybean oil consumption has grown by a significant magnitude.

It is in almost everything we eat; not only as a cooking oil but also in salad dressings and processed foods.

Specifically, domestic consumption of soybean oil has more than quadrupled from 1,652,000 tons in 1964 to 6,576,000 tons as of 2016 (9).

If we go even further back, soybean oil consumption increased 1000-fold between the years 1909 and 1999 (10).

Animal Studies Suggest Soybean Oil Could Be Obesogenic

If excessive soybean oil intake is helping to drive the obesity crisis, then isn’t that all just about calories in vs. calories out?

Well, calories certainly matter, and soybean oil contributes a substantial number of them to our daily diet.

However, some animal studies suggest that there could be more to it;

  • A mouse study compared the impact of a diet high in soybean oil to high fructose and coconut oil diets. In this study, the mice fed large amounts of soybean oil had statistically significant greater weight gain, diabetes, and insulin resistance. Additionally, the soybean oil diet upregulated cancer, inflammation and obesity-related genes (11).
  • Another animal study fed mice a high-fat diet of either soybean, olive oil, MCT oil, peanut oil, or tea oil. Following the study, body weight and body fat were significantly higher in the soybean oil group compared to all others.  Also, the soybean oil group had visible fatty liver disease—the MCT, olive oil, and tea oil mice did not (12).
  • In a study comparing butter and soybean oil, fat oxidation increased in the group fed butter. In the soybean fed group, subjects showed an inability to oxidize fat while resting (13).

Are these animal studies proof that soybean oil is obesogenic in humans?

Of course not, but with a lack of human trials on this issue, these animal studies certainly suggest it is worth looking into.

Key Point: Animal studies show that soybean oil uniquely causes obesity and diabetes compared to other fats. There is no evidence that this would be the same in humans, but it is perhaps an area for further research.

Refined, Bleached and Deodorized Oils May Contain Hexane Residues

Soybean oil manufacturers state that the finished oil doesn’t contain an appreciable amount of hexane because of the cleaning and refining process the oil undergoes.

However, studies show that residual amounts usually remain in the finished oil. Based on equivalent-dose animal studies, these amounts are safe for human consumption (14).

That being said, independent tests have investigated the issue and shown that hexane residues “10 times higher than what the FDA considers normal” can appear in soy products (15).

Additionally, the FDA has set no maximum values on hexane residues in soy products, and FDA regulation does not require testing vegetable oils for hexane contamination (16).

Key Point: Soybean oil may contain residues of the chemical solvent hexane.

Soybean Oil Promotes the Excessive Omega-6 To Omega-3 Ratios In Our Diets

As previously mentioned, soybean oil is a significant source of omega-6 fatty acids.

Although both omega-3 and omega-6 are essential fatty acids, some researchers believe we should consume them in relative balance.

For example, research shows that ancestral diets generally had an omega-6 to omega-3 ratio approaching 1:1 (17).

Due to the excessive amount of vegetable oils in the modern diet, people are consuming more omega-6 (and less omega-3) than at any point in human history.

Notably, estimates place the modern diet as having an omega-6 to omega-3 ratio of 20:1 or higher (18).

Omega-6: Healthy Until It’s Not?

Picture of a woman suffering from inflammation related back pain.Omega-6 is an essential fatty acid that is pro-inflammatory, and this is a good thing.

For instance, some inflammation in the body is necessary for healing cuts and wounds.

However, in excessive amounts, some research suggests that it may cause our body to stay in an inflammatory state — and chronic inflammation is a known risk for the majority of illnesses (19).

On this note, studies suggest that this excessive intake of omega-6 could cause the following problems;

  • As omega-6 competes with omega-3 for uptake into our cells, too much omega-6 could mean a deficiency of anti-inflammatory omega-3 (20).
  • Studies show that a lower dietary omega-6 to omega-3 ratio reduces inflammation and mortality risk from heart disease (21).
  • Chronic diseases such as diabetes, obesity, IBD and arthritis all have associations with increased omega-6. Imbalances in the omega 6 to 3 ratio have likely increased the prevalence of multiple inflammatory, disease-causing processes (22).

That said, this excessive omega-6 content is not a problem unique to soybean oil. Other oils rich in polyunsaturated fats such as grapeseed oil have the same problems.

Key Point: Soybean oil is in almost everything and significantly contributes to the excessive amounts of omega-6 in our diet. Some research suggests that this may have adverse health effects.

Soybean Oil Has Changed the Fatty Acid Composition of our Cells

Graph showing the rise in polyunsaturated fat consumption in the United States over the last century.
(Source)

The above graph shows the explosion in the consumption of polyunsaturated fat over the past century.

As soybean oil is the most significant source of omega-6 in the US, it is a significant part of this trend.

Excessive Omega-6 Intake May Cause Problems

As discussed, polyunsaturated fats have several double bonds, which means their carbon atoms are susceptible to oxidization.

The first thing to remember here is that our cells and tissues predominantly contain saturated and monounsaturated fat.

For one thing, this makes the fat in our cells stable. Just like vegetable oils can oxidize due to air, light, or heat exposure, so can fats inside our body.

One theory speculated on by researchers is that as our cell membranes incorporate a higher amount of polyunsaturated omega-6, they become less stable.

Several studies on soybean oil/omega-6 seem to offer some support for this theory;

  • Omega-6 is a “melanoma stimulator” because it makes our skin cells susceptible to damage from UV rays (23).
  • An animal study separated mice into different groups and fed them varying amounts of dietary omega-6 PUFA. The higher their dietary intake, the more they developed cancerous tumors (24).
  • One study fed female rats either soybean oil or ghee as 10% of their total diet. The soybean oil group had higher tumor incidence (65.4% versus 26.6%), larger tumor size, and more rapid onset of cancer (25).
Key Point: Excessive amounts of omega-6 change the fatty acid composition of our cells.

Final Thoughts

Overall, there is a lack of direct evidence from human trials to claim that soybean oil is harmful with any certainty.

However, in my view, many studies justify being wary about the potentially detrimental effects soybean oil can have.

Especially when we consider just how much of this oil many people consume.

To summarize; soybean oil is prone to oxidation, offers predominantly omega-6 fatty acids, and has links to adverse health effects in animal studies.

With all this being said, it is probably a better idea to opt for cooking oil that does not have these concerns.

Fruit oils such as avocado, coconut, and olive oil appear to be a good choice since studies show these oils have much better oxidative stability.

34
Leave a Reply

avatar
14 Comment threads
20 Thread replies
2 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
19 Comment authors
JorgeHectorRita WrightPete Mosstracy Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Jorge
Guest
Jorge

@Michael Joseph. Thank you for a well-written and informative article. I have a question about avocado and its oil. I have read elsewhere that avocado fruits, in spite of their otherwise richness in other nutritional elements, are very high in Omega-6 vs Omega 3. I don’t remember the exact figure but I think its somewhere around O-6:O-3 = 25:1 which is well above the commonly accepted beneficial level of 1:1 as you have pointed out. Realizing the adverse heath effect of excessive O-6, I have asked quite a few health/nutrition experts why avocado fruit, with its high ratio of 25:1,… Read more »

Hector
Guest
Hector

I bought a multivitamins and minerals supplement and on the box says antioxidant. Then I read the ingredients and the first ingredient is soybean oil and thought something is wrong here. Why those laboratories have to put soybean in multivitamins and minerals supplements? Thanks for the info!

tracy
Guest
tracy

wow – even the low carb foods all have soy bean oil – so frustrating– great article, thanks

Kris Grauel
Guest
Kris Grauel

I was prompted to read this article because I bought some tuna with soy bean oil in it by mistake. I will make sure going forward that whenever I buy tuna it is in water only.

Cindy
Guest
Cindy

As they point out, it’s hard to avoid. High time for the public to demand our food no longer be contaminated with this toxic industrial oil. There seems to be very little awareness out there of how it is put in just about everything. It makes great candles though…:)

Denise
Guest
Denise

Hi. I was wondering what might make dogs develop tumors quickly. My dog’s diet only consists of dog food and water. He’s a 12 year old Miniature Schnauzer and has started developing many fatty tumors. I have only been giving him filtered water and am now looking to the food I buy and looking even more closely to what’s in it. I feed him Castor & Pollux brand which includes 3% Omega-6 and saw in your article this was known to increase tumors in animals consuming high Omega-6. I was wondering if there was connection and if Soybean Oil in… Read more »

Javier
Guest
Javier

Obesity in the US has everything to do with hydrogenated vegetable oils (forbidden in Europe and only very recently forbidden in the US too), and using fructose syrup instead of natural sugar.
It has nothing to do with using vegetable oils. The vegetable oil market in the US is extremely deceptive

A. K.M Mohiuddin
Guest
A. K.M Mohiuddin

Thanks for the valuable information which is very important for people’s awareness about use of soyabean oil in food. We will be alerted in future about this oil. Thank you very much.

Pete Moss
Guest
Pete Moss

This makes me question why so many want the government controlling everything. If soy bean oil is so bad for me, why does the FDA allow the use of it?

Dejavu
Guest
Dejavu

Great article! Thanks!

Where can we get some extra Omega-3s to counterbalance the extra Omega-6 ?

I was buying Sunflower oil in lieu of canola and now need to find avocado oil that isn’t in a spray. Coconut and olive impart too much odd flavor when you are baking a cake!
I wonder will avocado oil?

Rita Wright
Guest
Rita Wright

Try refined coconut oil it has no taste. It is inhumane the way they market soy products claiming how healthy they are. I feel health food is another racquet of destruction for profit only. Soy also affects the way you think…mood swings, hostility. Also makes you feel weak and fatigued.

Roe
Guest
Roe

Why don’t people just workout? Always playing blame game

Shay
Guest
Shay

You are absolutely right. They do use canola or sometimes sunflower oil. I guess for me soybean oil has always been the worst but I know that canola isn’t a great option either.

EG
Guest
EG

Olive Oil, Walnut, Coconut and Sunflower are good choices. Mayo, Best Foods and others that contain soybean oil are poisonous. They are all trying to poison us.

Jessie
Guest
Jessie

Interesting, Chinese have consumed thousands of years soybean oil and they are definitely slimmer than the people from the USA. There are so many dietary, environmental, genetic factors which affect people’s health. it is overgeneralization by saying overweight of US people due to increased consumption of soybean oil. Soybean is not the only contributor to the mentioned diseases. By the way, there is also production procedure for soybean oil called ‘’cold pressing”.

EG
Guest
EG

They also have the highest rate of stomach cancer…..known fact.

jeff
Guest
jeff

used this for my science fair project thank you so much

Lisa Dietrich
Guest
Lisa Dietrich

Thank you for posting this informative and valuable article. I loved the way you would use the subjects and share their individual links. This article is a “keeper” for sure. It’s one that needs to be read several times as to retain the information stated here. God bless.